When I read this from the NYT this morning:
In five short days, Americans have begun to wonder if their country is actually breaking.
It started last Thursday, with the Microsoft outage. Then, on Friday, came the nationwide flight stoppage, only the third this century. After that, four major U.S. banks reported tech problems on Monday, the same day United Airlines’ computers went down. On Tuesday morning, the National Security Agency’s internal communications network was offline, then Apple services were disrupted.
The cascading series of tech failures left Americans stranded in airports, refreshing their work computers, and generally scratching their heads over what was actually happening. Was some massive hack causing a near-simultaneous shutdown of our digital arteries? Were rogue A.I. agents at work? Or was it more about the aging bones of a 20th century nation unready for the 21st, where one router and a few copper wires in Arkansas could cause everything to go kerflooey?
Perhaps most importantly, was anyone at the helm to fix it?…
,,, it reminded me of something I had meant to write about Friday night, but didn’t have time for (and then the news peg was over). What I was thinking about during those couple of hours when all flights in America were on hold is basically what the last line of that NYT excerpt raises. And the headline: “A National Meltdown With Nobody at the Help Desk.”
Of course, the crisis on my mind Friday night was over after a couple of hours. But it had a lot of people feeling, shall we say, up in the air for those couple of hours. And I was one of them. My wife was at a high school reunion in Florida, and due to fly back the next day. In fact, I later learned, one of her classmates was leaving the reunion that night, and was in the middle of the necessary hour-plus ride to the airport with the news about the grounding broke.
Aside from personal inconvenience and anxiety for travelers and those waiting for them, there were larger questions while that stoppage endured. The initial reporting, from The New York Times down to the least reputable rumor mill, was sketchy. At least when the aircraft industry was grounded on Sept. 11, 2001, we knew what had happened. This time, we knew zilch. And this seemed like a pretty large-scale reaction to zilch.
Was it an urgent national security threat? Those won’t always take the form of the Twin Towers coming down on live television. Was it the first step of a cyberattack that would take down our communications, our electricity grid, military targeting systems, and so forth, in preparation for… what?
Probably not. It was probably a glitch in one place that caused the FAA to be overcautious. But we still didn’t know, and in that couple of hours I heard a number of rumors: AI had been put in charge of our flight control systems, and it failed. Or the opposite — a creaky system that should have been replaced decades ago had finally collapsed under the load.
It was a good time for someone to give us an explanation, and assure us that things were under control, and that the people handling it knew what they were doing.
Who would that be? In other times, it would have been the President of the United States. I’ve suggested before that our nation has gotten a bit overdependent on that source of assurance. But sometimes, that’s the one person in the country who is in position to speak to the problem. And something that involves a federal agency shutting down a vital system that it controls seems like one of those times.
But we don’t have one of those. We have a gross parody of a leader in the White House. And voters know it, as they demonstrated earlier this month. Worse, in his second administration he has filled thousands of positions under him with people who are as unqualified and unbalanced as he is — or at least are willing to give the world that impression.
Suppose the head of the FAA went on live national television. Would you recognize that individual? Would you think “well, he must know what he’s doing or he wouldn’t have gotten the job?” Probably not, unless you are among the diminishing subset who think our current situation is just fine.
The rest of us are holding our breaths waiting for these people’s fingers to be off the button. And while many are encouraged after the recent election that perhaps we’ll be able to breathe again soon, I’m not terribly reassured.
First, as I keep saying Donald J. Trump isn’t the problem, or not the entire problem. He’s just an expression of this ignorant, destructive madness we call Trumpism. Suppose he dropped dead tomorrow? If we survived J.D. Vance long enough to have another election, what Pied Piper would the Republicans then start following?
Oh, but you say don’t worry, the Democrats just showed they’re coming back? That’s not so comforting. I saw a notification on my phone to an item that sickened me. It was to something looking forward to 2028, and it mentioned only two names: Kamala Harris and… AOC. I’m sorry I didn’t take a screenshot of it, but I promise I am not making this up.
Those apparentlhy were our two alternatives to the present mess: A demonstrated loser and someone who’s very initials translate as “unacceptable to the political center.” Not even a slight nod to qualifications, or electability.
In recent years, the Democratic party has been locked in a war between the kinds of sensible people who would elect an FDR or a Truman or a Johnson or, yes, a Biden… and people who want someone who reflects their own political fantasies, without regard to what most of the country wants. And guess which faction gets most of the publicity?
Sometimes one side of that split wins a primary, and sometimes, shockingly, the other gang wins a big one. So no, “a Democrat” is not the solution. The solution is a candidate who appeals to:
- The Democrats who reflect their parties’ traditions of middle.- and working-class concerns — jobs, economic growth, basic fairness and a place for everybody at the table, with no one being dismissed because they are not ideologically “correct.”
- Republicans who had the sense to be horrified when Trump first came on the scene, but kept voting for him once he captured the nomination because that made him a “Republican,” and they didn’t see the other party even pretending to offer anyone (except Joe Biden in 2020), who respected them despite their differing affiliation.
- Those of us in the middle who distrust both parties, and are always looking for someone who seriously tries to appeal to a consensus of the country. Only someone like that can even begin to heal what’s wrong with America.
Only someone who appeals to all those groups can get up in front of the country and reassure us that things are OK — or if they aren’t OK, that we can pull together and solve the problem.























